How to Choose the Right Realtor in Jacksonville, FL: A Guide for Buyers and Sellers

Written by Tara Lezama | Nov 22, 2026, 2:56:40 AM

What to look for, what questions to ask, and what to know before signing a real estate agreement in Florida.

Choosing a real estate agent is one of the most important financial decisions you will make when buying or selling a home. The right professional can help you protect your investment, negotiate effectively, avoid costly mistakes and navigate the process with confidence.

But how do you know which agent is right for you?

Whether you are buying your first home, selling a longtime residence, relocating to Northeast Florida or purchasing an investment property, this five-step guide will help you make an informed decision. It is the same standard we encourage prospective clients to apply to every agent they interview, including us.

Step 1: Get clear on your goals first

Write down what a successful result looks like before you speak with anyone. A realtor can only be measured against goals you have named.

If you are buying

  • Your price range and the monthly payment you are comfortable with
  • Your must-haves and deal-breakers, such as commute, neighborhood feel, flood zone, age of the roof and systems, or new construction
  • Your timeline, and whether you need to sell a home first

If you are selling

  • The net amount you need after the mortgage payoff and closing costs
  • The date you need to be out, and how flexible that date is
  • How much preparation, repair and staging you are willing to take on

Bring these notes to every interview. How closely each candidate listens to them tells you a great deal.

Step 2: Verify the license, brokerage and credentials

Any agent can say they are experienced. Verification takes five minutes and does not depend on what they say.

  1. License status. Search the agent's name in the Florida Department of Business and Professional Regulation (DBPR) license lookup at MyFloridaLicense.com. Confirm the license is active, see which brokerage holds it, and check for any disciplinary history. Also note whether the agent is a broker associate or a sales associate. A broker associate has met Florida's additional broker licensing requirements.
  2. Brokerage. Confirm the brokerage on the license matches the company on the agent's marketing and on the agreement they hand you.
  3. REALTOR® membership. REALTORS® commit to a code of ethics that other licensees do not. Ask whether the agent is a member and with which local association.
  4. Designations. Letters after a name can matter, but only when they relate to your situation. Ask what the designation required and how the agent has used it for clients like you. For example, the Certified Residential Specialist (CRS) designation is the highest credential awarded to residential sales agents, and it is earned through the Residential Real Estate Council.
  5. Recent local activity. Ask for the agent's closed transactions in your neighborhood or price range over the past twelve months, not a lifetime total.

Step 3: Five questions worth asking

You do not need a long list. These five show you how an agent works day to day.

  1. Who will I work with, and who covers when that person is unavailable? A strong answer names real people and a clear backup.
  2. How will I hear from you? A strong answer sets the rhythm of updates up front and explains what you will hear after an offer, an inspection and an appraisal.
  3. How do you work with my lender? A strong answer shows that the agent and the lender share one timeline, so loan approval, appraisal and closing dates never surprise you.
  4. Which contract deadlines should I watch, and how will you track them? A strong answer names the inspection, loan approval and closing dates, explains them in plain language and keeps you ahead of each one.
  5. When you recommend a price or an offer, how will you explain it? A strong answer shows the comparable sales and the reasoning, gives a clear recommendation and tells you the next step.

Later in this guide, we answer these same five questions ourselves.

Step 4: Red flags to watch for

  • A price that is too good to be true. An inflated list price to win your business, or a low offer strategy with no supporting comparable sales, usually costs you later.
  • Pressure to sign immediately. A good agent welcomes your questions and your time to compare.
  • Vague answers. Specific numbers, addresses and dates should come easily.
  • Reluctance to put terms in writing. Services, fees and the length of the agreement all belong on paper before you sign.

Step 5: Understand the relationship and the agreement before you sign

Two things are put in writing before you work with a realtor: the kind of relationship you will have and the agreement that sets the terms. Read both fully, and ask the agent to explain anything you do not understand.

Transaction broker or single agent: what is the difference?

Florida law presumes that a licensee works as a transaction broker unless you agree otherwise in writing. Here is how the two most common relationships compare.

  Transaction broker Single agent
Level of representation Limited representation Fiduciary representation
How it begins Florida's presumed relationship Established through the appropriate written disclosure
Confidentiality Limited confidentiality Full confidentiality duties
Serving both sides of a deal May provide limited representation to both parties Cannot act as a fiduciary for both parties

Transaction brokerage is a limited form of representation, not a fiduciary one, with duties set by statute: dealing honestly and fairly, disclosing known facts that materially affect a home's value and are not readily observable, accounting for all funds, using skill, care and diligence, presenting all offers and counteroffers, and keeping your negotiating position confidential, such as your motivation or willingness to pay more or accept less, unless you agree otherwise in writing. Many buyers and sellers value the approach because it keeps the focus on a smooth, fair transaction that serves both sides well, and because Florida does not allow dual agency, one agent never acts as a fiduciary for both sides of a deal.

Florida law also recognizes a third option, no brokerage relationship, in which the licensee owes more limited duties, such as dealing honestly and fairly and disclosing known facts that materially affect value. Whichever relationship your agent offers, confirm that the agreement you sign matches it.

The buyer broker agreement

Since August 2024, an agent who is a REALTOR® and MLS participant must have a signed written agreement with a buyer before touring a home, in person or by live video. Florida Realtors publishes the Exclusive Buyer Brokerage Agreement, Transaction Broker (EBBA-8tb). Whichever agreement you are handed, check these items:

  • Services. What the agent will do for you, in specific terms
  • Compensation. How the agent is paid, who pays and when. Compensation is negotiable and is not set by law
  • Length of the agreement. A shorter initial term gives both sides a chance to confirm the fit
  • Cancellation. How either side can end the agreement and what that costs, if anything
  • Exceptions. What happens if you buy outside the agent's efforts, such as new construction or a private sale

Showing agreements

If you are not ready to sign an exclusive agreement, ask about a showing agreement. Unlike an exclusive buyer brokerage agreement, a showing agreement is non-exclusive, so you are not bound to one brokerage. Florida Realtors publishes the Showing Agreement (SA-5) for this purpose. Florida's default relationship is transaction broker, so signing a showing agreement does not create a single-agent relationship unless additional disclosure is given. If you later decide to work together more closely, the terms of an existing agreement can be changed in writing.

If you are selling

Sellers sign a listing agreement. Review the same items: services, compensation, length, cancellation and what happens if the home sells outside the agent's efforts.

This guide is general information, not legal advice. Forms are revised from time to time, so ask your agent for the current version. For questions about contract language, consult a Florida real estate attorney.

Why local experience matters in Northeast Florida

An experienced Jacksonville-area real estate professional should be able to help you understand how factors such as these may affect your purchase or sale:

  • Flood zones and homeowners insurance
  • CDD assessments and HOA fees
  • Roof age and insurance eligibility
  • Condominium reserves and special assessments
  • New construction incentives and builder contracts
  • Property taxes after a change of ownership
  • Market differences across Duval, Clay, St. Johns and Nassau counties

Ask each candidate for a specific example of how they have handled one of these for a client.

Realtor interview and comparison checklist

Fill this in during or right after each interview. Score each item from 1 (weak) to 5 (excellent), add up the totals, and use the notes row to capture anything the score does not show.

What to compare Agent 1 Agent 2 Agent 3
Name and brokerage      
License active on DBPR (yes/no)      
Closings in the past 12 months in my area (number)      
Relevant experience and credentials (1–5)      
Who I work with, and the backup (1–5)      
Communication expectations (1–5)      
How they work with my lender (1–5)      
Plan for tracking contract deadlines (1–5)      
Pricing and negotiation strategy (1–5)      
Marketing strategy, if I am selling (1–5)      
Compensation and cancellation terms are clear (1–5)      
Total score      
Notes      

Want a printable copy? Enter your name and email below and the printable checklist opens right away.

How The BB Group Realtors measures up

We hold ourselves to the same questions. Here is how we answer them, and what stands behind each answer.

1. Who will I work with, and who covers when that person is unavailable?

You work with two licensed professionals, not one. Our team includes a Broker Associate who holds the Certified Residential Specialist (CRS) designation, along with ABR, GRI, SRS and SFR designations, and a partner who works every transaction alongside her. We review each other's work, so every contract, disclosure and offer packet gets two sets of eyes, and a transaction coordinator supports us on the paperwork. If one of us is unavailable, someone who already knows your file is always ready to step in.

2. How will I hear from you?

In writing, at each step, so you always have a record to refer back to. We also keep everyone on the same page with a group chat that includes you, both agents and, as needed, the transaction coordinator. Before an offer goes out, we send a summary of the price, deposit, inspection period, closing date and exclusions, with the full packet attached. When the offer is submitted, we confirm it, and we report back as soon as there is news from the seller or the listing agent. If you are selling, you receive an update on activity once a week, and we use a showing app to schedule appointments and collect feedback from every showing.

3. How do you work with my lender?

You are free to use any lender you choose, and we coordinate with whoever you select. Our team also includes a licensed mortgage loan originator, so we understand what a lender needs, how long each step takes and where financing can run into obstacles. We explain the loan application and loan approval deadlines in your contract in plain language, so nothing about financing is a surprise. If you are paying cash, we make sure your proof of funds and your deposit instructions are in order before the offer goes out.

4. Which contract deadlines should I watch, and how will you track them?

Before you sign, we send a written summary of the deadlines that apply to you: the deposit, the inspection period, the loan application and approval dates, the flood zone review and the closing date. We explain that your deadlines begin on the effective date, not the day you sign, and we recommend scheduling your inspection right away so it is completed early in the inspection period. Our agents and our transaction coordinator track every date together, so each deadline is managed from the day the contract is signed through closing.

5. When you recommend a price or an offer, how will you explain it?

Every recommendation starts with the reason. We tell you what we know about the seller's priorities and how your offer compares, then lay out the offer structure and any requests to the seller in plain, labeled sections. We summarize the strategy in one sentence, and we ask for a clear yes from you before anything is submitted. You see the full contract, the compensation agreement and the required disclosures before you sign, and you sign electronically once you are comfortable.

Our relationship with you. We explain the role and the duties in writing at the start, and we walk through the Florida Realtors buyer broker or showing agreement with you line by line before you sign.

Beyond the closing table. Our team also manages rental properties throughout Northeast Florida, so we can speak to rental potential, maintenance costs and the long-term costs of owning a property, which matters if you are buying an investment or deciding whether to keep or sell.

Frequently asked questions

How do I verify a real estate agent's license in Florida?

Search the agent's name in the Florida Department of Business and Professional Regulation license lookup at MyFloridaLicense.com. You can confirm that the license is active, see which brokerage holds it and check for any disciplinary history.

Do I need to sign an agreement before touring a home in Jacksonville?

If the agent is a REALTOR® and an MLS participant, yes. Since August 2024, a signed written agreement is required before touring a home with a buyer, in person or by live video. It can be an exclusive buyer brokerage agreement or a showing agreement, so ask which form the agent uses and what it commits you to.

Are real estate agent commissions negotiable in Florida?

Yes. Compensation is not set by law. It is agreed in writing between you and the agent, so review it before you sign and ask what it covers.

What is the difference between a REALTOR® and a real estate agent?

Every REALTOR® is a licensed real estate professional, but not every licensed agent is a REALTOR®. A REALTOR® is a member of the National Association of REALTORS® and commits to its Code of Ethics.

Can I interview multiple real estate agents before choosing one?

Yes, and we encourage it. Interview at least two or three, use the checklist above, and choose the agent who answers your questions most clearly.

What is the difference between a transaction broker and a single agent?

A transaction broker provides limited representation with duties set by Florida law, and Florida presumes this relationship unless you agree otherwise in writing. A single agent owes fiduciary duties, including full confidentiality, and is established in writing. See the comparison table in Step 5.

Should I hire the same real estate agent to buy and sell my home?

Often, yes. One agent who knows both transactions can coordinate the timing of your sale and your purchase. Ask whether the agent has recent experience on both sides and how they would manage overlapping deadlines.

Your next step

We would welcome the chance to be one of the agents you interview. Bring your goals, your questions and this checklist, and we will walk through our plan for your purchase or sale.

Thinking about new construction? Join our New Build List to hear first about new communities in Northeast Florida: https://www.thebbgrouprealtors.com/new-build-list 

The BB Group Realtors, Coldwell Banker Vanguard Realty
Email: Tara@thebbgrouprealtors.com
Phone: 904-445-9175

About the Author

Tara Lezama is a Broker Associate with Coldwell Banker Vanguard Realty, co-founder of The BB Group Realtors, a Certified Residential Specialist (CRS), a licensed mortgage loan originator and a U.S. Army veteran.

She serves buyers, sellers and real estate investors throughout Northeast Florida, bringing experience in residential sales, property management, mortgage lending and real estate industry leadership. She serves as the 2027 president of realMLS.

Her approach emphasizes informed decision-making, transparent communication and protecting clients' financial interests through every stage of the real estate transaction.